Are you a small business owner looking for ways to boost holiday sales and grow your email subscriber list? In this mini case study, we’ll walk you through the real-life example of Charming Candle Co., an artisanal candle maker that used targeted email marketing to achieve a 25% lift in holiday revenue. Learn how they revamped their sign-up process, segmented their audience, and implemented automated email workflows to transform their seasonal marketing results.

Introduction: The Importance of a Robust Email Marketing Strategy

In today’s crowded online marketplace, small businesses often struggle to stand out—especially during the busy holiday season. With rising advertising costs and fierce competition, email marketing remains one of the most cost-effective and direct ways to reach potential customers. However, success depends on having the right strategies in place, such as compelling sign-up forms, audience segmentation, and post-purchase follow-up campaigns.

Charming Candle Co. used these tactics to expand its email list and boost holiday sales. Below, we’ll dive into the key steps they took, the challenges they faced, and the impressive results they achieved.The Challenge: Low Holiday Sales & Outdated Email Practices

Despite having a beautifully curated website and high-quality handmade soy candles, Charming Candle Co. faced a major hurdle:

1. Outdated Sign-Up Forms
   The business had a basic, hard-to-find newsletter sign-up widget that failed to entice visitors. As a result, new subscribers trickled in at a slow rate.
2. Limited Segmentation
   All subscribers received the same generic newsletter, regardless of whether they were first-time buyers or repeat customers, leading to low open and click-through rates.
3. Minimal Holiday Promotion
   Although they had a variety of candle scents perfect for gift-giving, they lacked a strong seasonal email plan to drive holiday-specific sales.

Without a proper incentive for website visitors to join their email list or a strategy to tailor messages to subscriber interests, the business couldn’t capitalize on the high traffic and gift-buying frenzy of November–December.

The Strategy: Four Key Steps to Transform Holiday Marketing

Charming Candle Co. partnered with an email marketing platform to revamp their approach. Here’s how they made it happen:

1. Revamped Email Capture

• Pop-Up Sign-Up Form: Instead of relying on an unnoticed footer sign-up box, they added a stylish pop-up offering 15% off the first purchase.
• Dedicated Landing Page: A well-designed landing page—linked from social media ads—reinforced the discount incentive and provided a frictionless subscription experience.

Why It Works
Pop-ups, when used thoughtfully, can significantly boost sign-ups by creating an eye-catching, time-sensitive offer. Offering an immediate benefit (like a discount) gives visitors a compelling reason to opt in.

2. Segmented Lists for Personalized Content

• Interest-Based Segmentation: The team split subscribers into distinct groups—“seasonal buyers” interested in holiday-themed scents and “year-round enthusiasts” who shop for everyday aromatherapy.
• Personalized Emails: Each segment received emails highlighting different product lines or special offers. For example, seasonal buyers got advanced previews of limited-edition winter scents, while loyal fans were reminded of classic favorites.

Why It Works
Segmented emails see higher open and click-through rates because they speak to the subscriber’s unique interests or past behavior. When people feel the content is relevant to them, they’re more likely to engage—and purchase.

3. Festive Email Campaigns

• “12 Days of Candles” Series: A festive countdown campaign introduced a new limited-edition scent or holiday bundle each day, keeping subscribers excited and checking their inboxes regularly.
• Eye-Catching Visuals: Dynamic GIFs, colorful holiday-themed imagery, and bold call-to-action buttons enticed readers to shop the newest offers.

Why It Works
Seasonal marketing campaigns with a clear theme and timeline build anticipation. Spreading out promotions across multiple days or weeks creates a sense of urgency and encourages repeat visits.

4. Automated Post-Purchase Follow-Up

• Thank-You Email: Every buyer automatically received a personalized thank-you message with a referral code to share with friends and family.
• Upsell Opportunities: The email also suggested complementary products, like wick trimmers or mini candle sets, to drive additional sales.

Why It Works
Automated follow-up emails keep customers engaged after their initial purchase. Showing gratitude and offering a referral code encourages word-of-mouth promotion, while suggesting related products can boost average order value.

The Results: 25% Lift in Holiday Sales & Rapid List Growth

By combining targeted segmentation with engaging holiday campaigns, Charming Candle Co. achieved impressive results:

• 30% Increase in Subscriber Growth
  The discount pop-up and dedicated landing page helped the business collect 700 new email addresses in just one month—double their usual growth rate.
• 25% Lift in Holiday Sales
  The “12 Days of Candles” series and strategic promotions brought in a quarter more revenue compared to the previous holiday season.
• 40% Open Rate on Segmented Campaigns
  By sending highly relevant content to each subscriber group, Charming Candle Co. saw their open rate jump from 25% to 40%. Customers were more eager to learn about new scents and exclusive deals catered to their interests.

Key Takeaways for Small Businesses

1. Offer Immediate Value
   Incentives like a discount or free shipping are excellent motivators for new email sign-ups. Make it simple and compelling.
2. Embrace Segmentation
   Tailor messages based on your subscribers’ past purchases, browsing behavior, or stated interests. Personalized content performs better.
3. Plan Seasonal Campaigns
   Stand out during holidays with themed campaigns that build excitement and leverage festive visuals and countdowns.
4. Automate Follow-Ups
   Don’t miss the chance to re-engage customers post-purchase. Sending a simple thank-you can encourage loyalty and drive referrals.

How You Can Implement These Strategies

If you’re looking to replicate Charming Candle Co.’s success, start by:

1. Auditing Your Current Email Capture Methods: Are your sign-up forms easy to spot? Is there a clear incentive for new subscribers?
2. Segmenting Your Subscriber List: Create at least two segments to serve different customer interests.
3. Designing a Themed Holiday (or Seasonal) Campaign: Schedule a series of emails that build anticipation and highlight new or limited-edition items.
4. Automating Your Follow-Ups: Set up post-purchase workflows that thank new customers and offer additional promotions or helpful resources.

Conclusion: Small Changes, Big Impact

Charming Candle Co.’s experience proves that even a few strategic tweaks—like updating sign-up forms, segmenting emails, and adding post-purchase automation—can make a significant difference in holiday sales and year-round growth. Whether you sell candles or consult as a freelancer, these core email marketing principles can help you stand out in a noisy online space.

By implementing segmentation, personalized offers, and clear value propositions, your small business can replicate this success—converting more site visitors into subscribers, improving engagement rates, and ultimately, boosting revenue.

Want More Email Marketing Tips?

Looking for more in-depth advice on how to grow your list, plan seasonal campaigns, or automate your post-purchase emails? Check out our latest guides and resources to elevate your email marketing game and keep your subscribers excited year-round!

© 2025, Vertical Response. All rights reserved.